M3 SMG vs. 6 Speed.. What's faster???

[luvdatbimmer]

I just ordered the M3 Convertible. I am aware that it isn't as fast as the coupe, but I am just wondering in general if the SMG (Sequential Manual Gearbox) is comperable to the 6 speed manual in performance?? Thanks!!!

 

[epj3]

I believe the SMG is faster as the gear ratios are about the same (if not the same?) and the shifting speed makes up for a REALLY little bit of time. Plus, smg has the shift lights that help you time the shifts perfectly. With manual you could shift a little too late or a little too soon.

 

[mikev]

its not so much that one is faster than the other its about driver envolvment. some people prefer it as it makes them feel like a racer some prefer it becuase its easy to use and theres no left leg numbness in this heavy crimbo traffic. the clutch on the 6 speed allows greater control and gives a VERY special driver the edge. Even then were only talking tenths or even hundredths of seconds differance (so a headlights length then!!)

 

[luvdatbimmer]

I am aware on the faster gear changes.. .08 seconds for the SMG in the most aggressive mode!!! I do love driving manual, but I know other family members will want to drive this car that don't know how to drive manual. I will also not teach them on my car, LOL!!!

 

[mikev]

I am aware on the faster gear changes.. .08 seconds for the SMG in the most aggressive mode!!! I do love driving manual, but I know other family members will want to drive this car that don't know how to drive manual. I will also not teach them on my car, LOL!!!

So manual it is then, don't want them spoiling your leather wheel now do we

 

[flashinthepan]

I believe the SMG is faster as the gear ratios are about the same (if not the same?) and the shifting speed makes up for a REALLY little bit of time. Plus, smg has the shift lights that help you time the shifts perfectly. With manual you could shift a little too late or a little too soon.

Link ?

I have only read the 6-sp as faster vs SMG in Car magazines.[???1]